Some recent progress , and a down turn in the existing engine.
First the good news
My parts order has arrived , including the springs , retainers , locators , locks and the spring pad cutting tool. The sanding and blending continues and is nearing completion , looking good too ! I also ordered a pushrod length checker which is an adjustable / variable length pushrod , used for mock up , to determine the optimal length that the pushrod should be , when custom length pushrods are being ordered. The last time I ordered shorter pushrods I subtracted the amount of material machined from the cylinder head and block when those were resurfaced and decked , from the length of the stock pushrod , to determine what length of pushrod to order. This works well and allows the lifter to live happily with out being overly compressed , as can happen when using pushrods that are too long. The length checker tool is a more professional way of doing this , being a sucker for gadgets and a certified tool junkie , I just had to have one to add to the valvetrain tool collection.
Now the bad news
Last week a second rocker arm has failed on the way to our club winter camping trip. This happened just south of Longview , strangely within a mile or so of last years rocker arm breakage , that time on the way home. The first incident was north bound on # 22 , the #5 intake rocker broke in half. This time it was the #3 intake. I turned around returned home and changed out all twelve rocker arms , back to the stamped steel stock rocker version , outside in the yard during a howling blizzard , then headed out to make the camping trip without further incident . The engine ran flawlessly for the remainder of the trip. Now , the mystery is , why am I breaking rockers ? , AND , why are some of the other rocker arms showing evidence of the roller tips being side loaded and chewing into the aluminum rocker arms ? . At this stage I can only speculate .
My theory ......... normally in V8 applications , using roller rockers , guide plates are installed under the studs which fasten the rocker arm to the head , to align the pushrods and keep the rocker arms centered over the valve tips , this tends to keep all the parts aligned and happy , getting along together. The mopar performance rocker arms for 4.0 / 2.5 applications do not call for the use of guide plates , resulting in , what I feel to be a lack of stability. The design of Mopar rockers places them in pairs on a shaft , a pair for each cylinder. The rocker arms are located axially on their shaft with thrust washers and retaining rings. They are held down with a 5/16" cap screw , passing through the shaft and a small spacer / pedistal , two being used for each pair of rocker arms. Also , pushrods in these engines are quite long , would there possibly be some sort of flexing / deflection / harmonic deal going on , contibuting to the instability of the valvetrain ?
Until I figure this out or get an answer , I'll not be using roller rockers. I have seen the use of other brands , such as Crower ( AMC V8 ) and guide plates ( OLDS ) on a 4.0 head , requiring some extensive modifications . Whether this is worth it , was a success or not is a grey area , the guy who masterminded it had issues with pushrod / guide plate material incompatability resulting in severe wear / damage to the pushrods. Also I'm aware of a few guys using other brands of roller rockers , some having been in use for a very short time period , I hope this ( my ) situation is unique to Mopar roller rockers and doesn't affect these brands . I'd suggest to these persons , that they moniter and keep an eye on this , it takes very little time to pull a valve cover for inspection.
PICS OF THE FIRST BREAKAGE , Note ! in this pic , the pushrod looks bent , it's not , the picture simply makes it look that way.
What's a real issue here is , it's about a G note to install this junk , including the 1/2" spacer required for the valve cover and thermostat housing , two high end ( reusable ) Felpro valve cover gaskets are $140!!!!