Sahara = Dana 30 up front = 37's may not be a good idea, even if you could fit them with flat fenders or a body lift.
I would go with 35's. You'll need either spacers or new wheels to prevent the wider wheels from rubbing on your suspension components...and other things. You may also find that those gears are a little tall to be running with 35's. Many folks with 35's on a JK indicate that 4.88's or 5.13's seem to be a good fit.
If you've got an automatic transmission, you'll probably end up having to swap out your front driveshaft (the boot on the CV joint tends to contact the crossmember/skidplate for the auto tranny). With four inches of lift, you may have to swap out your rear driveshaft as well (or you may not...YMMV)
What sort of lift did you put on? Did you also get adjustable control arms?
If/When you go to larger tires, you will probably also want to reprogram your computer to reset your transmission's shift point and keep your Speedo accurate. AEV makes a gizmo that will do that for about $200. Northridge sells them.
If your play will be "sometimes", you might be well served by the all terrain tires that JPthing recommends. Some MT tires can be...interesting...to drive in the winter