i am glad people are speaking up. There is no 'right' answer just opinions.
i will clarify Lance. IF i am on trail anywhere i will not charge...ever. IF i am on trail and come across someone stuck and drunk, they will remain stuck. IF i come across someone stuck and 'off trail' , ie; CLOSED SENSITIVE area, i will leave them stuck. Count on this.
Now as someone who has come out of a wheelin trip at Maclean and packing up at the store to head home 'countless' times where a 'walker' asks for help, i have done it many times...no charge, no reimbursement for wrecked straps, wrecked winchline, time, gas,etc. All for the LOVE of my fellow 4x4 enthusiasts.
Fast forward to the internet world. Info is so readily available that as a NEWBIE you really have no excuse for doing solo adventures UNPREPARED. So, if they walk out and call a rescue truck like Extreme (years ago) or LemonAid Jay now, they will wait longer and they will PAY. Paying me $100 for my time is reasonable. In this day and age of areas being shut down, the evidence seems to support the "newbie" not in a club or on a 4x4 forum as the culprits. When i see any thread regarding closures, its preaching to the choir because anyone on these sites KNOWS better. Its the one timer MUD finding crowd that is killing us, so i have changed my good citizen attitude a bit.
Tom