I have insurance with ING for my house and my family vehicle, they are cheapish, but the guy I go thru is a buddy from wayyy back, and he covers for me quite well. I know I pay a bit more, but I also know I have coverage. My jeep is thru him as well, however I have corporate insurance on that so the rates are quite high.
I would fully recommend dropping a 50$ or so gift card from the Keg (or wherever) on your agent if you dont know them. Make them remember you and appreciate you, and they will stand up for you.