I've run the following:
33x12.5x15 Yokohama Mud Diggers @ 6Lbs (Toyota)
33x12.5x15 Big O XT @10Lbs (Toyota)
33x12.5x15 Swampers @ 8Lbs (Toyota)
33x12.5x15 TRXUS MT @11Lbs (TJ)
31x10.5x15 MT/R @11Lbs (TJ)
30x9.5x15 BFG AT KO @15Lbs (XJ)
All of the 33's were on 8 wide...the 30 and 31 were on 7 wide.
I agree with Bnine, depends on the tires construction and compound, vehicle, terrain and driving style.