The best advice I have got since you a running a 17 or 18 and doing lots of city driving like myself....
1. Try and go with a skinny tire if you are driving onthe road lots, maybe something that comes out to 35x11.2 or whatever I don't really know the size options available, This will make road handling, mpg, and wear on components noticably less
2. Get a lighter tire, I here toyo's are great but heavy
As for the brand, I would say any big name Goodyear MTR, BFG KM2, and many other big names will have comparable tires. Really whatever you can get a deal on or like the most
Best site I have found for comparing tires
http://www.offroaders.com/tech/AT-MT-Tires/Goodyear-Wrangler-MTR.htmAll the different tires in the lefthand colum, just click and you have acess to dozens of reviews in differing condtions