I know for sidewall puncture, any sidewall damage replace the tire.
I got a puncture right on the edge of the tread, its still in the tread.
Very slow leak, probably lasted 2 days before automatic sense went off on Acura but tire ground buldge looked alright (didnt measure psi) leaked most likely due to temperature change from unheated garage to outisde. Found 3 or 4 days ago, 2 days before sensor went off, 4th day now wife went to tire store.
Tire is All Weather I believe, or All Season, I dont think it matters. Will confirm later tonight.
Screw was left in place, screws head doesnt look that big but shaft could be a long one.
My initial thought was just repair it because it was in the tread.
Tire guy says replace it because its All Weather/All Season.
Wife dealt with tire store. So thats why I question.